The Original Papa Nick’s Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Why pick this one
The Original Papa Nick’s has served family recipes for over 50 years, including pizza, calzones, stromboli, and garlic rolls in Mars Hill.
Best for
- Homestyle pizza in Mars Hill
- BBQ pork pizza with pulled pork and red onion
- Italian meals including calzones, stromboli, hot subs, and salads
- Take-out or online pizza ordering
- Casual catering
Look elsewhere if
- Monday or Tuesday orders, when the restaurant is closed
- Late-night meals after the posted 8 PM closing time
- Dining-room service on Wednesday, Monday, or Tuesday
Specialties
- Homestyle pizza
- BBQ pork pizza with pulled pork and red onion
- Calzones
- Stromboli
- Garlic rolls
- Italian dishes, hot subs, and salads
What makes them different
- Founded by Jerry and Lila Nikla in 1970 and still family owned and operated
- Mars Hill location opened in 1991
- Original pizza dough and marinara recipes remain unchanged from the founder's recipes
- Offers a dining room, deck seating, take-out, and online ordering
- Provides a casual catering menu
- Years in business
- 50
- Serves
- Mars Hill
Distilled from this business's own website.
Contact & Location
- Address
- 15 College St, Mars Hill, NC 28754
- Phone
- (828) 689-8566
- Website
- http://www.theoriginalpapanicks.com
- theoriginalpapanicks@gmail.com
Services
- Dine-in Italian restaurant service
- Take-out orders
- Online ordering
- Casual catering