Cheese Shop in Orange, North Carolina

2 found · ← All categories in Orange

Updated October 31, 2026

Boxcarr Handmade Cheese

Cheese Shop

Cedar Grove, NC

Boxcarr Handmade Cheese makes farmstead goat-and-cow cheeses, offers twice-weekly farm pickup, and has received American Cheese Society awards.

  • farmstead goat-and-cow cheese
  • soft bloomy-rind cheeses such as Cottonbell and Cottonseed
  • aged and semi-firm cheeses such as Redbud and Nimble

1 or 2 day UPS or FedEx shipping

Hillsborough Cheese Company

Cheese Shop

Hillsborough, NC

Hillsborough Cheese Company handcrafts small-batch European-style cow- and goat-milk cheeses, including Bloomin’ Sweet Ash, Carolina Blue, feta, Gouda, and Manchego.

  • Customers seeking small-batch European-style cheeses
  • Customers seeking cow- or goat-milk cheeses
  • Customers seeking vegetarian cheeses made with vegetable rennet

Other categories in Orange

Cheese Shop in nearby counties

FAQ

Which Orange County cheese maker offers farm pickup?

Boxcarr Handmade Cheese offers farm pickup on Tuesdays and Saturdays.

Can I order Orange County cheese for shipping?

Boxcarr offers shipped cheese assortments and subscriptions, with a stated UPS or FedEx shipping time of one or two days.

Which local cheeses are made with vegetable rennet?

All Hillsborough Cheese Company cheeses use vegetable rennet and are vegetarian.

What types of milk are used by local cheese makers?

Boxcarr uses farmstead goat milk and locally sourced cow milk. Hillsborough Cheese Company makes cheeses from locally sourced cow’s and goat’s milk.