Italian Restaurant in Cumberland, North Carolina

14 found · ← All categories in Cumberland

Updated October 30, 2026

Capri Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Capri Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria offers gluten-free pizza crust and pasta, 17-inch pizzas, and delivery through DoorDash, SLICE, and ChowNow.

  • Gluten-free pizza or spaghetti
  • Large specialty pizzas
  • Pizza by the slice

Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Gusto Napoletano serves VPN-compliant, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza made by a certified VPN pizzaiolo in Fayetteville.

  • Authentic Neapolitan pizza
  • Wood-fired pizza prepared under VPN guidelines
  • Handmade ravioli and regional Italian pasta specials

Antonella's Italian Ristorante

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Antonella's Italian Ristorante serves scratch-made traditional and original Italian food from a downtown Fayetteville location, using recipes passed down through Antonella's Sicilian family.

  • Traditional Italian dining in downtown Fayetteville
  • Scratch-made Italian food
  • Dining featuring Sicilian family recipes

Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills

Italian Restaurant

Hope Mills, NC

Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills offers carryout-only Italian food with pizza, gluten-free options, desserts, and a kids menu.

  • carryout Italian meals
  • pizza orders
  • gluten-free menu options

Luigi's Italian Restaurant

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Luigi's Italian Chophouse and Bar has served its Fayetteville location since 1982, offering homemade pasta, hand-cut steaks, fresh fish, and over 300 wines.

  • Italian dinners featuring homemade pasta and sauces
  • Meals combining Italian dishes with hand-cut steaks or fresh fish
  • Private parties and gatherings for up to 100 guests

Pierro's Italian Bistro

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Pierro's Italian Bistro offers brick oven pizza, an outdoor patio in historic downtown Fayetteville, and catering, with family ownership since 2002.

  • brick oven pizza
  • Italian dining in historic downtown Fayetteville
  • outdoor patio dining

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Carrabba's Italian Grill offers Spaghetti Carbonara, weekday lunch, delivery, carside carryout, catering, and group events in Fayetteville.

  • Fayetteville diners seeking Italian lunch or dinner
  • Customers ordering Spaghetti Carbonara
  • Takeout or carside carryout orders

Fazoli's

Italian Restaurant

Fayetteville, NC

Other categories in Cumberland

Italian Restaurant in nearby counties

FAQ

Which Cumberland County Italian restaurants offer gluten-free options?

Capri offers gluten-free pizza crust and gluten-free spaghetti. Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills lists gluten-free menu options as well.

Where can I get authentic Neapolitan pizza in Fayetteville?

Gusto Napoletano makes VPN-compliant Neapolitan pizza with hand-stretched dough and 60-to-90-second wood-fired cooking.

Which Italian restaurants can handle a large private event?

Luigi's has two private dining rooms that together accommodate up to 100 guests and also offers catering and family-style takeout. Gusto Napoletano books events featuring scratch-made Italian cuisine.

Which Fayetteville Italian restaurants offer takeout or delivery?

Capri accepts delivery orders through DoorDash, SLICE, and ChowNow. Carrabba's offers carside carryout and delivery through delivery partners, while Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills is carryout and pickup only.

Do Fayetteville Italian restaurants require reservations?

Carrabba's Fayetteville location does not offer traditional reservations, though an app-based waitlist is available at participating locations. Reservation policies for the other listed restaurants are not provided here.