Thrift Store in Orange, North Carolina

15 found · ← All categories in Orange

Updated October 31, 2026

My Secret Closet

Thrift Store

Hillsborough, NC

My Secret Closet offers women's clothing in sizes 0–4x, junior accessories, men's wear, and home décor from its Hillsborough store.

  • Women's clothing shoppers seeking sizes 0–4x
  • Junior shoppers looking for prom dresses and accessories
  • Men seeking affordable casual or professional clothing

Goodwill Industries Of Eastern Nc, Inc. - Hillsborough

Thrift Store

Hillsborough, NC

Goodwill Industries of Eastern NC, Inc. - Carolina Shores offers used clothing, books, household goods, and furniture at published prices in Calabash.

  • Budget-conscious shoppers seeking used clothing
  • Shoppers looking for books, DVDs, household goods, or furniture
  • Donors seeking a Calabash donation center

The Consignors

Thrift Store

Chapel Hill, NC

The Consignors runs monthly online auctions with approximately 500 lots, nationwide bidding for shippable items, and Chapel Hill warehouse pickup.

  • shopping for curated secondhand furniture, collectibles, art, jewelry, books, and vintage items
  • buyers comfortable with timed online auctions
  • buyers seeking shippable estate-sale items nationwide

Clothes Mentor

Thrift Store

Chapel Hill, NC

Clothes Mentor offers authenticated designer items and resale clothing, with select merchandise priced up to 70% below original prices.

  • shopping for authenticated designer clothing
  • finding discounted women's clothing or menswear
  • buying resale handbags or jewelry

Habitat ReStore

Thrift Store

Hillsborough, NC

Habitat ReStore offers daily-changing furniture, appliances, and building materials across five Triangle locations, with markdowns every two weeks.

  • Furniture and home decor shoppers
  • Home renovation projects needing used building materials
  • Customers seeking vintage or antique items

GCF #26

Thrift Store

Hillsborough, NC

Extraordinary Thrift Store

Thrift Store

Carrboro, NC

Extraordinary Thrift Store offers daily new clothing, books, home goods, and decor in Carrboro, with discounts up to 75%.

  • Budget-conscious clothing shopping
  • Finding vintage and collectible items
  • Shopping for books, records, DVDs, or CDs

Other categories in Orange

Thrift Store in nearby counties

FAQ

How does consignment work at My Secret Closet?

Consignments run for 60 days. Consignors receive 40% of the selling price up to $99 and 50% for items selling above $100.

Are thrift-store prices negotiable?

Habitat ReStore states that its prices are non-negotiable, but merchandise discounts occur every two weeks and can reach 60%. Goodwill items are sold as-is, with all sales final.

Where should I look for used furniture or building materials?

Habitat ReStore specializes in used furniture, appliances, windows, plumbing, lumber, flooring, doors, and cabinets. Its merchandise changes daily based on donations.

Can I buy vintage or collectible items locally?

Extraordinary Thrift Store carries vintage and collectible items, while The Consignors offers curated online auctions featuring collectibles, antique furniture, jewelry, watches, and rare books.

Can I shop The Consignors like a regular walk-in thrift store?

No. The Consignors runs monthly online auctions, typically with about 500 lots. Local shoppers can arrange one-on-one Thursday preview appointments, and immediate purchases are not available before an auction closes.