Pizza Restaurant in Madison, North Carolina

5 found · ← All categories in Madison

Updated October 31, 2026

Vinyl Pies Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

Hot Springs, NC

Vinyl Pies serves 10- and 14-inch specialty pizzas at 164 Bridge Street in Hot Springs, with dine-in music and beer, wine, and cider.

  • Dine-in pizza near the Appalachian Trail
  • Customers seeking specialty pizzas with pesto, Alfredo, buffalo, BBQ, or red sauce
  • Groups wanting pizza alongside beer, cider, wine, or non-alcoholic drinks

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

Marshall, NC

Hunt Brothers Pizza offers 10 toppings at no extra charge, with locations inside convenience stores and corner markets.

  • Customizing a pizza with multiple meat and vegetable toppings
  • Buying pizza from a convenience store or corner market
  • Single-serving Hunk A Pizza purchases

Hunt Brothers Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

Mars Hill, NC

Hunt Brothers Pizza offers 10 toppings at no extra charge, with locations inside convenience stores and corner markets.

  • Customizing a pizza with multiple meat and vegetable toppings
  • Buying pizza from a convenience store or corner market
  • Single-serving Hunk A Pizza purchases

The Original Papa Nick’s Italian Restaurant

Pizza Restaurant

Mars Hill, NC

The Original Papa Nick’s has served family recipes for over 50 years, including pizza, calzones, stromboli, and garlic rolls in Mars Hill.

  • Homestyle pizza in Mars Hill
  • BBQ pork pizza with pulled pork and red onion
  • Italian meals including calzones, stromboli, hot subs, and salads

BoRudys

Pizza Restaurant

Mars Hill, NC

Other categories in Madison

Pizza Restaurant in nearby counties

FAQ

Which Madison-area pizza option has gluten-free or vegan choices?

Vinyl Pies lists both a gluten-free crust and vegan cheese. Its gluten-free crust is not prepared in a gluten-free environment, so it may not suit strict gluten-free dining.

What pizza sizes are available?

Vinyl Pies lists 10-inch and 14-inch pizzas. Hunt Brothers offers a 12-inch pizza or a quarter-pizza Hunk A Pizza serving.

Where can I order pizza with more than just pizza on the menu?

Papa Nick’s lists calzones, stromboli, garlic rolls, hot subs, salads, and other Italian dishes. Hunt Brothers lists wings, WingBites, and breakfast pizza.

Can I order pizza for takeout or online?

Papa Nick’s offers takeout and online ordering. The provided information does not confirm online ordering or delivery for Vinyl Pies or Hunt Brothers.